First off, thanks for the Chistmas card Jeff. We appreciate it a lot!
On another thread a poster suggested that Jw's inherently are 'Christian' due to restraint in the matter of not killing each other in warfare.
I don't see dubs as "Christian" because they don't go to war, but I do think the reverse almost has to be true about a "true" Christian, just by definition.
A person first has to -has to - ask what is a Christian? That means many things to many peope. But... At the most very basic level it means "To be Christ like". Whatever else a person believes about being Christian, or about doctrine, that definition has to be at the heart of it. If not, what is the Christian believing in?
I hate to sound cliche (and I really, really despise the phrase I'm typing here), but the phrase "What would Jesus do?", comes to mind.
Assuming the gospels in the NT Bible (any translation/version) is an accurate representation of what happened during Jesus' (supposed) life, then do we ever read of him advocating his followers going to war? I mean in the physical, here and now sense, not in some future spirit war where non-believers are destroyed.
I can think of only one instance where he even asked the disciples if they had weapons on them for use. The witchtower spins it as protection from animals, but even if it was for personal protection, it definetly wasn't in the context of going to war.
So, back to what I said in the beginning, "What would Jesus do?" (shudders)
If Christians are to be "Christ like", can anyone picture him prone on a hiitop, in a sniper position, eye to the scope, crosshairs across the forehead of an "enemy", and then pulling the trigger, blowing the back of the "enemies" head out with the bullet? Would he do that? Really? What is written that he said to do to our "enemies"? "Put a bullet through their head"....No, it was, "Love your enemies" - isn't that right? If you can't picture Jesus doing something, then to follow in his foot steps, a Christian, any Christian, shouldn't either.
I will never defend the witchtower, they don't deserve it, but they did have some things right in their bible teachings.
This ofcourse brings up the whole hornets nest of what do we do about the Hitlers of the world if we can't go to war and still be "true" Christians. Oops, the witchtower explains that as well. Don't be part of the world. Bible says that pretty plain. Damn, guess they got something else right.
I suppose I'm being blunt, but if you want to believe in the Bible, then you can't have your cake and eat it to.